2 more. 1-1 with the Rams, 0-1 with Zona.

 

I stand corrected. I forgot they lost to the Pats.

I stand corrected. I forgot they lost to the Pats.

 

Don't remind me

Here are QB's with good numbers who are not in the HOF - Vinny Testaverde, Drew Bledsoe, Kerry Collins, Dave Kreig, Boomer Esiason, Phil Simms, Ken Anderson, Kurt Warner.

 

If McNabb gets in, should some of these players be in? As I look at your list of HOF'ers, I see a difference between them and the QB's not in the HOF. IMO McNabb is closer to my list of those not in than your list of those who are in.

 

One more item I will throw in for consideration. Pro football reference.com has a stat called Weighted Career Value. It is a sabermetric type stat that tries to rank all players, regardless of position. Something very ironic about that stat. McNabb is ranked 95th on that list and is tied with ... Randall Cunningham. Here is a link:

 

NFL Career Approximate Value (Weighted) Leaders - Pro-Football-Reference.com

 

I always thought Ken Anderson should be in anyway, great qb in my opinion...Warner will probably make it in at some point when eligible.

 

However, with that stats site...any site that's gonna list Brett Farve that high (7th on that chart) then to me it can't be much of a formula, has to be a flaw somewhere because he just shouldn't be that high in my opinion. Just not and never a fan.