I'm worried about the rotation when the post season comes. Maybe I'm nuts but that's what I'm thinking about.

 

I'm more worried about post season match ups and being on the road than the Pirates or Cards.

Maybe but my math is accurate. It was still just you and GT which is a total of two people. LRCW posted numbers and said it's not clear who should start at 3B. That isn't saying what you're saying.

I feel like I presented an opinion as opinion. I did however point out that factually Frazier has more hits, runs, HR's and RBI's since the break than Rolen so my opinion is he has been more productive.

 

Let's rewind since the topic of discussion seems to be ever changing. This is what you said to kick it off.

 

Let's play that game where we compare Frazier and Rolen's numbers since the all star break.

 

Maybe the people who were dead wrong on that fun game will admit it soon.

 

These were the numbers at the time.

For the record, since the All Star Break

 

 

Rolen--.364 Avg, 3 HR 12 RBI .451 OBP

 

Frazier.. .299 Avg, 7 HR, 22 RBI, .341 OBP

 

 

I love Frazier, I think he needs to play everyday, I just don't think it's so cut and dry that Rolen is the one that needs to sit when Votto returns. Frazier can play other positions.

 

What you said implied that Fraziers' numbers were clearly better since the break, and you were looking to rub some noses in what was your opinion being fact. The numbers clearly didn't back up that stance. That's where I stand. Done. Next...

Those numbers weren't totally accurate bc he had another HR and 2 more RBI's and a higher avg Now you are admitting though that I was implying something which is totally different than presenting something as fact. And you left off the post where I said Frazier should be at 3rd which was my point.

 

I have asked you twice and you still haven't answered why totally ignore HR and RBI numbers when comparing them? I want the run production.

Those numbers weren't totally accurate bc he had another HR and 2 more RBI's and a higher avg Now you are admitting though that I was implying something which is totally different than presenting something as fact. And you left off the post where I said Frazier should be at 3rd which was my point.

 

I have asked you twice and you still haven't answered why totally ignore HR and RBI numbers when comparing them? I want the run production.

 

I didn't ignore anything. Go back to the first two things you said to start this. Both have very good numbers since the break. Some favor one, some the other. That isn't the slam dunk, looking to make people feel dumb point you were trying to make that started this. Pretty simple, really.

 

Like I said. Done. Next...

I'm worried about the rotation when the post season comes. Maybe I'm nuts but that's what I'm thinking about.

 

Nice to meet you Nuts.

Nice to meet you Nuts.

I've been called worse.

I didn't ignore anything. Go back to the first two things you said to start this. Both have very good numbers since the break. Some favor one, some the other. That isn't the slam dunk, looking to make people feel dumb point you were trying to make that started this. Pretty simple, really.

 

Like I said. Done. Next...

 

Again you're implying something or guessing my intentions which is different from stating a fact which is what you said I did. I never said in there that Frazier had clearly better numbers. When pressed on the issue I said Frazier was better at baseball than Rolen.

Again you're implying something or guessing my intentions which is different from stating a fact which is what you said I did. I never said in there that Frazier had clearly better numbers. When pressed on the issue I said Frazier was better at baseball than Rolen.

 

Let's play that game where we compare Frazier and Rolen's numbers since the all star break.

 

Maybe the people who were dead wrong on that fun game will admit it soon.

 

S. M. H...

Frazier still has horrible plate discipline. Big game, big AB, I'll take Rolen all day.