September 21, 200521 yr Author BTW, private schools are not being kicked out of the KHSAA but a separate class is being proposed. They can still chose to be members of the KHSAA.This is laughable. If this is the case. Here is how your playoffs would look: In A - 8 teams, statewide. And there hasn't been a state champ in A in 50 years, at least in football, wy punish the little people. AA - 2, what a playoff that would be. AAA - 1, show up, your state champ!!! HOOOO RAY, when's the parade. AAAA - 3 , holy cow, Trinity and X playing for the 5th time this year.
September 21, 200521 yr This is laughable. If this is the case. Here is how your playoffs would look: In A - 8 teams, statewide. And there hasn't been a state champ in A in 50 years, at least in football, wy punish the little people. AA - 2, what a playoff that would be. AAA - 1, show up, your state champ!!! HOOOO RAY, when's the parade. AAAA - 3 , holy cow, Trinity and X playing for the 5th time this year. And again you are stating from a view that life revolves around football. KHSAA has several other sports that your playoffs would look a lot different.
September 21, 200521 yr Author And again you are stating from a view that life revolves around football. KHSAA has several other sports that your playoffs would look a lot different. Ok, how many private schools do you think there are state wide?
September 21, 200521 yr Author Do this.... Take T&X out and rework your numbers....and get back to me. What I stated originally is true. The problem is T&X and they are punishing other schools for it. ladiesbballcoach? was I right on this one?
September 21, 200521 yr Ok, how many private schools do you think there are state wide? 48. That was in the Herald Leader article. 280 schools in KHSAA. Private schools make 17% of the member schools.
September 21, 200521 yr ladiesbballcoach? was I right on this one? I don't think so. I would say there are some other schools, albeit Louisville/Lexington private schools that have possibly won more state championships over the past 10 years. I would say Sacred Heart or Lexington Catholic has the most state team championships over the past 10 years. They have won the last 5 in girls basketball.
September 21, 200521 yr A private school has won the last three 3A girls state cross country state titles and eight of the last 11 1A girls state titles. I agree that the issue transcends past football.
September 21, 200521 yr For the sake of arugment, take out Trinity/X/Assumption/Sacred Heart and what does that do to the percentages? (I have no idea, because I haven't done it). Also, who were the runners up in all the sports?
September 21, 200521 yr For the sake of arugment, take out Trinity/X/Assumption/Sacred Heart and what does that do to the percentages? (I have no idea, because I haven't done it). Also, who were the runners up in all the sports? In girls basketball, Lex Catholic was runnerup to Sacred HEart twice, I believe.
September 21, 200521 yr For the sake of arugment, take out Trinity/X/Assumption/Sacred Heart and what does that do to the percentages? (I have no idea, because I haven't done it). Also, who were the runners up in all the sports? If we are going to pick and choose which schools to pull out of the equation, than we should pick and choose some public schools to pull out of the equation also?
September 21, 200521 yr Author If we are going to pick and choose which schools to pull out of the equation, than we should pick and choose some public schools to pull out of the equation also? No, I really think the moajority of these guys see T& X and see no way to compete, the issue is not the small 1a and 2a or even the 3a, schools they see T&X and hate them. Take them out and see what the numbers do.
September 21, 200521 yr No, I really think the moajority of these guys see T& X and see no way to compete, the issue is not the small 1a and 2a or even the 3a, schools they see T&X and hate them. Take them out and see what the numbers do. The numbers were quoted in the Herald Leader article and I took them from there. Have no clue on the total numbers so cannot figure that up.
September 21, 200521 yr If we are going to pick and choose which schools to pull out of the equation, than we should pick and choose some public schools to pull out of the equation also? No, but my question is, without T/X/A/SH, are the runners up consistently the same schools?
September 21, 200521 yr I think a better question would be are the same schools losing to them in the semi-finals.
September 21, 200521 yr Author The numbers were quoted in the Herald Leader article and I took them from there. Have no clue on the total numbers so cannot figure that up.I'll bet if you take T&X out the number of State Title's won by a private school are under 10%, out of 17% of the school's.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.