June 30, 200818 yr Only one New York Giant made the list. Osi Umenyiora being the only one. Not a great list IMO... Just because your a Giants fan doesn't mean they should be on there ha. Who else merrit's a spot. I am a huge bengals fan and I would love to see TG or big Willie on the list but the fact is they shouldn't be.
July 1, 200818 yr Just because your a Giants fan doesn't mean they should be on there ha. Who else merrit's a spot. I am a huge bengals fan and I would love to see TG or big Willie on the list but the fact is they shouldn't be. Plaxico Burress? Justin Tuck? Chris Snee? Antonio Pierce? There's a few that deserve consideration.
July 1, 200818 yr Plaxico Burress? Justin Tuck? Chris Snee? Antonio Pierce? There's a few that deserve consideration. I would maybe consider Burress, but probably none of the others.
July 1, 200818 yr I strongly feel that I should be somewhere in the top 50 NFL players to not be drafted, picked up by a team, or play any college ball. Yup I'm a beast on the field...:fight:
July 1, 200818 yr Burress should definatly get a look especially ahead of Andre Johnson I don't think he should be so high. But top fifty is high for Plaxico I mean he did catch 12 TD's but only caught 70 balls and just barely over 1000 yards for the season, I can think of two bengals recievers who statistically had better years and at least 3 or 4 others who were better.
July 1, 200818 yr Mario Williams at 6? I don't understand that he has only played about 8 games at a pro bowl level, those being his second half of last year.
July 1, 200818 yr Burress should definatly get a look especially ahead of Andre Johnson I don't think he should be so high. But top fifty is high for Plaxico I mean he did catch 12 TD's but only caught 70 balls and just barely over 1000 yards for the season, I can think of two bengals recievers who statistically had better years and at least 3 or 4 others who were better. He played the season with a ton of injuries... When healthy Burress can dominate. I'm not saying he's the best WR in the game, but he is a top 50 player IMO.
July 1, 200818 yr I would maybe consider Burress, but probably none of the others. Chris Snee will be considered one of the top guards in the game soon. He just signed a huge deal. He's been on the verge of making the pro bowl the last 2 years (voted in as an alternate). He should make it next year. Tuck is the same. He hasn't gotten a ton of PT because he's been behind Strahan and Umenyiora, but in limited time he still got 10 sacks. Pierce was a pro bowler at MLB. I can see why they are left off the list as many people may not have heard of them. But in a year or two I believe Snee and Tuck will be considered among the best at their positions.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.