March 9, 200719 yr Yes. That is not the problem. The problem is that the people who have held power in the region throughout history have been the most radically minded. The Quran DEFINATELY uses language that allows for the continuance of militarist domination. It can be used as a tool to radicalize the masses towards a path of welcomed death. In short, its teachings to lead towards a path that sways far from peace. We must pursue OUR interest in the area, not the interest of those that would like to see the establishment of a muslim based military and economic superpower in the middle east. It is not that there is NO WAY its teachings will allow for peace, it is that there is NO WAY that the radical leadership in the area will allow for peace. The same could be said of the Bible, Ram. We can't pursue our interests in that region until there is stability there. There won't be stability there until there is some sort of compromise and peace. It is in the best interests of everyone to help the region learn to deal with their differences in a mutually beneficial manner.
March 9, 200719 yr The same could be said of the Bible, Ram. We can't pursue our interests in that region until there is stability there. There won't be stability there until there is some sort of compromise and peace. It is in the best interests of everyone to help the region learn to deal with their differences in a mutually beneficial manner. I beg to differ, we have and still can pursue our interest in the region without their being compromise and peace. We have gotten the Saudi government in our pockets through thier huge investments in our markets. Current leadership in Iran would like to see the Saudi royal family put to death as traitors to their people and religeon for this type of interaction with the U.S. This type of mentality doesn't lend itself to peaceful coexistance with the United States.
March 9, 200719 yr How did I get brought into this? I don't know, I guess you become used to debating with certain people.
March 9, 200719 yr I beg to differ, we have and still can pursue our interest in the region without their being compromise and peace. We have gotten the Saudi government in our pockets through thier huge investments in our markets. Current leadership in Iran would like to see the Saudi royal family put to death as traitors to their people and religeon for this type of interaction with the U.S. This type of mentality doesn't lend itself to peaceful coexistance with the United States. Let me ask this: There's all this hoopla about us being in Iraq to establish democracy. Democracy cannot exist in a Theocracy. Therefore, if we're in Iraq to establish a democracy, then shouldn't it stand to reason that we could help establish democracies in other countries? I'm not saying I believe we can actually establish Democracy. I'm saying that I believe we can assist in the establishment of a peaceful co-existence of varied "ocracies".
March 9, 200719 yr Let me ask this: There's all this hoopla about us being in Iraq to establish democracy. Democracy cannot exist in a Theocracy. Therefore, if we're in Iraq to establish a democracy, then shouldn't it stand to reason that we could help establish democracies in other countries? I'm not saying I believe we can actually establish Democracy. I'm saying that I believe we can assist in the establishment of a peaceful co-existence of varied "ocracies". On this we can agree, however I think the level of assistance that I have in mind is different than yours. I think without our continued military assistance, these ocracies will always be controlled by the few who are willing to be the most militant.
March 9, 200719 yr Sorry....I was confused....mea culpa! No problem. I am sitting this one out, just reading and admiring, go Camel.:lol:
March 9, 200719 yr On this we can agree, however I think the level of assistance that I have in mind is different than yours. I think without our continued military assistance, these ocracies will always be controlled by the few who are willing to be the most militant. Then we've been arguing with two different philosophies, not knowing where each was coming from. :lol: :thumb:
March 9, 200719 yr No problem. I am sitting this one out, just reading and admiring, go Camel.:lol: Until I got to the end of your post, I was feeling pretty good about myself! :lol:
March 9, 200719 yr Until I got to the end of your post, I was feeling pretty good about myself! :lol: Well, I should have clarified myself. Reading and admiring both posters. Go Camel.:thumb: Is that better on the ego?
March 9, 200719 yr Well, I should have clarified myself. Reading and admiring both posters. Go Camel.:thumb: Is that better on the ego? That'll work!
March 9, 200719 yr Then we've been arguing with two different philosophies, not knowing where each was coming from. :lol: :thumb: I prefer the tern healthy debate rather than argue.:lol: :thumb:
March 9, 200719 yr I prefer the tern healthy debate rather than argue.:lol: :thumb: Me too! :thumb: See, we can agree!
March 9, 200719 yr Rockmom, there is no disrespect intended when I make this statement, but you need to further study the history of the Muslim people and their religeon. It is a society based on conversion and military triumph. Their sects have been fighting against one another since the last of the four rightly guided caliphs died, leaving a void in their religeous leadership. Peaceful solutions of compromise are not part of their history to the point that compromise is looked at as a source of weakness. Iran would love to help solve the problem. They are the most militant anti-U.S. government in the region. They would love to control Iraq's resources, creating a muslim superpower. This could create a nuclear superpower in the middle east that could create a shift in military and economic power globally. This is NOT in the United States interest. Well, boys, you'd better be prepared to fire up the draft then. We've become entangled in something that could easily last 1000 years and our volunteer military cannot sustain the level of deployment required to beat down every Islamic hothead who chooses Iraq as a vacation spot. Make sure you tell all those soldiers and marines on their third or fourth deployment to forget about their families back home because this could take a while. Better get your checkbooks out while you're at it. Although we've skillfully deferred the costs for this adventure, at some point China and Japan will stop lending us money.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.