17 hours ago, Voice of Reason said:

Or proof of who the truly great QB's are?

So we are saying Rodgers isn't truly one of the greatest?

This year did him no favors in the argument but how many times has he had the Packers offense put up 30+ and lose a playoff game?

1 hour ago, MJAlltheWay24 said:

So we are saying Rodgers isn't truly one of the greatest?

This year did him no favors in the argument but how many times has he had the Packers offense put up 30+ and lose a playoff game?

I don't dismiss some of the poor defenses Rodgers has had in the past factoring into some of his post-season success, or lack thereof.

And this may not make sense, because it doesn't factor into anything number wise, but for years I have viewed Aaron Rodgers as a poor leader, aloof, and diva-acting. I don't think his teammates accordingly respond in the biggest moments. Again, there is nothing empirical about my theory, but instilling confidence in your team is part of the success formula. His last two exits have been bad. Don't forget last year - I know Tampa scored 31 - but Brady handed them three INTs in the second half and he only generated 7 points. Cancelled out by the late pick Rodgers threw in the first half, then Tampa scored a TD.

4 hours ago, MJAlltheWay24 said:

So we are saying Rodgers isn't truly one of the greatest?

This year did him no favors in the argument but how many times has he had the Packers offense put up 30+ and lose a playoff game?

I am saying maybe he isn't as great as Montana and Brady. Maybe a couple orhers as well e.g. Peyton Manning. The measuring stick for greatness in the NFL is Super Bowls and Super Bowl wins. Right now, Rodgers is somewhere on the spectrum of QB's with one Super Bowl win. Off the top of my head, I would put Rodgers along with Dan Marino.