Survivor: Caramoan Fans vs Favorites II

[MJAlltheWay24]

I love that they are bringing Phillip back haha!

 

I might have to look up some pictures because I honestly don't remember who a lot of those people are.

[formerkywrestler]

 

They bring Rob back again I will quit watching. Let me re-phrase that they bring Rob back in any scenario other then all past winners (which would be way cool) and I quit watching.

 

A show of only winners would be a lot of fun.

[Randy Parker]

A show of only winners would be a lot of fun.

 

Agreed, but didn't they do that once before?

[formerkywrestler]

Agreed, but didn't they do that once before?

No. Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains had I believe 4 people who were winners at the time of the show but that's the most they've ever had.

[formerkywrestler]

I love that they are bringing Phillip back haha!

 

I might have to look up some pictures because I honestly don't remember who a lot of those people are.

Recap:

 

John Cochran - Season 22 - Whiny

Brandon Hantz - Season 23 - Crazy

Phillip Sheppard - Season 22 - Awesome

Corinne Kaplan - Season 17 - Semi-hot.

Francesca Hogi (Season 22) - Don't remember much even after looking at her picture.

Dawn Meehan (Season 23) - Whiny

Brenda Lowe (Season 21) - Hot

Andrea Boehlke (Season 22) - Hot

Erik Reichenbach (Survivor 16) - Dumbest Survivor contestant ever. Gave away his immunity necklace to Parvati's crew in Micronesia.

[UKMustangFan]

I think an "Winners" season would be awesome, but another I think would be great is a season of past contestants that were voted out first.

 

Or one that featured a tribe of all past winners vs. a tribe of all past contestants voted out first. :idunno:

[Randy Parker]

No. Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains had I believe 4 people who were winners at the time of the show but that's the most they've ever had.

 

Thanks. That must have been what I was thinking of.

[Godot]

but another I think would be great is a season of past contestants that were voted out first.

That would be interesting

[NEERFAN]

Erik Reichenbach (Survivor 16) - Dumbest Survivor

 

The Ice Cream dude.

[MJAlltheWay24]

Erik Reichenbach (Survivor 16) - Dumbest Survivor

 

The Ice Cream dude.

 

Had to look up his picture, and now that I see it I definitely agree!

[MJAlltheWay24]

Had to look up some pictures:

 

I somehow forgot all about Cochran, but glad he's back because he makes me laugh, even though he is a little annoying.

 

I liked Brandon Hantz when he was on the show, but coudl do without him again. Be interesting to see how he plays in regards to "respecting his family name" and all that nonense.

 

Love that Phillip is back.

 

I liked Andrea.

 

Brenda had a little attitude to her game from what I can remember.

 

I feel like Dawn got on my nerves, could do without her.

 

Don't really remember much of Francesca or Corinne

[All Tell]

Dawn is there simply because she and Cochran were close, in fact she was really the only person from his season that bonded with him.

 

Back to the whole past winners thing. We have enough now that we could have 2 tribes of 9 all previous winners. In other seasons returning winners have had a big target on their backs. I would probably also like to exclude Sandra since as the only 2 time winner she would be targeted. Everyone should be on even footing.

[formerkywrestler]

Had to look up some pictures:

 

I somehow forgot all about Cochran, but glad he's back because he makes me laugh, even though he is a little annoying.

 

I liked Brandon Hantz when he was on the show, but coudl do without him again. Be interesting to see how he plays in regards to "respecting his family name" and all that nonense.

 

Love that Phillip is back.

 

I liked Andrea.

 

Brenda had a little attitude to her game from what I can remember.

 

I feel like Dawn got on my nerves, could do without her.

 

Don't really remember much of Francesca or Corinne

Dawn was unbearable. All-in-all this was a weak set of returnees.

[GrizzlyAdams]

The only thing I remember about Francesca was that Phillip kepy pronoucing her name wrong at the tribal she was voted out. She was getting angry. I wonder what Phillips tag line will be this time around. Secret SWAT Member?