April 27, 200917 yr Author None of those questions apply to what I asked. I'd have no problem with Rosales or Janish replacing Edwin or Gonzalex for a short period of time. Neither Rosales or Janish is the long-term answer. Neither is Gonzalex. Edwin may or may not be capable. But when I brought up the possibility of Janish playing over Gonzalex, it was belittled because Janish didn't get through the minors quick enough & had already proven that he was not a capable MLB hitter throughout his minor league career. THAT was my point. Gonzales showing improvment at the plate doesn't apply to whether or not the Gonzo and E-5 situation is the same? :lol:
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.