Eli Manning or Aaron Rodgers Part II

[PurplePride92]

New thread. Same question.

 

Should I start Eli Manning against the Dolphins in Miami on Monday Night Football?

 

Or

 

Should I start Aaron Rodgers against the Dallas Cowboys at home on Sunday?

[PurplePride92]

Eli is projected to give 24.

 

Aaron is projected to give 26.

[PurplePride92]

In this league passing TDs are 6 points. You also get bonus points for long TD plays.

 

40-49 yard TD play is worth 9 points.

 

50-99 yard TD play is worth 11 points.

[RondoRules]

What about Eli or Jameis vs the Saints?

[PurplePride92]

For the year Eli has scored 361 points for an average of 30.1 points a game.

 

Aaron Rodgers has been a below average Aaron Rodgers this season without Jordy Nelson. He has scored 352 points for an average of 29.3 points a game.

[PurplePride92]

What about Eli or Jameis vs the Saints?

 

I think I'd play Jameis against the Saints over Eli.

 

And Jameis is available on our waiver wire I think. Sigh......

[PurplePride92]

I also have Odell Beckham, James Jones and Jarvis Landry on this team. Not playing James Jones though.

[PurplePride92]

Yeah, Jameis was available. Just picked him up.

 

So now throw him into the mix. :lol2:

 

 

Eli, Aaron or Jameis against the absolute worst defense in the league?

[PurplePride92]

The Cowboys have done a good job defensively against QBs when it comes to fantasy points and Aaron has been a roller coaster all season.

 

The Dolphins suck against the pass and the Saints are awful defensively period.

 

Is Aaron Rodgers still an "always start regardless of the matchup" QB this season or is the best thing to play matchups at this point?

 

I need to win to make the playoffs this week. Win and I'm in. Lose and I need some help to get in.

[halfback20]

What about Eli or Jameis vs the Saints?

 

Anyone vs the Saints

[halfback20]

It's hard to predict what the Giants offense will do. They might go on a 4 game tear, or they might fall completely apart.

 

One thing I can guarantee is that they will lead 80-90% of the game, only to lose it in the final minutes.

[MJAlltheWay24]

Anyone vs the Saints

 

Let's roll the dice on Jameis!

[statman]

With the weather forecast in Green Bay today calling for 100% chance of rain and Rodgers inconsistent play, I would have to go Eli.

[PurplePride92]

I'm going with Eli. Screw it.

[PurplePride92]

Eli was the right choice. He has 27 points through the third quarter. Aaron finished with 24.