I hate that rule. Stupid.

 

To me doing what Randle just did is no different than someone alone near the end zone and they drop the ball before crossing the goal line (Jackson, Trevethaen)

Randle is stupid. Should be a fumble and the Bears ball.

 

It was close either way. He still had his hand on the ball when he got touched.

Jacobs with another rushing TD.

I hate that rule. Stupid. To me doing what Randle just did is no different than someone alone near the end zone and they drop the ball before crossing the goal line (Jackson' date=' Trevethaen)[/quote']

 

It's a little different since he is actually laying on the ground.

It's a little different since he is actually laying on the ground.

not that different. He was paying attention but the refs rewarded him for a mental mistake. The rule is dumb and it benefits players that happen to make dumb mistakes.

If they have the opportunity to draft him, do you think they draft Clowney?

 

I probably would. Depends on what pick you have an what they could get for it on the trade market (I don't see them drafting a QB with the #1 or #2 pick when they have Eli, so they could shop it). Clowney's smart, he don't play for free. If he needs a few months to heal up an injury, and you bring him in and he interviews well, etc. then it's not like you've lost that much if he's been taking the time he needs to heal up.

not that different. He was paying attention but the refs rewarded him for a mental mistake. The rule is dumb and it benefits players that happen to make dumb mistakes.

 

He wasn't trying to gain any yards. He gave himself up. Its different IMO. Stupid play no doubt but its different IMO.

I was screaming for intentional grounding there :lol2:

I was gonna say what a stupid penalty. Haha

How bout Brandon Jacobs? 100 yards rushing with 2 TD's.

You cannot blame that on Eli....

You cannot blame that on Eli....

I know someone who can.

I expected more out of Brandon Myers this year. He's terrible though.

You guys acted like he hit him in stride. I've seen that pass caught and a better TE probably would have, but it was high. It's a shame, Eli recovered well from a truly awful start.

You guys acted like he hit him in stride. I've seen that pass caught and a better TE probably would have' date=' but it was high. It's a shame, Eli recovered well from a truly awful start.[/quote']

It did look a little high. That's the Giants luck this year tho...tipped ball hits the db in stride.