If you are going based on this years stats, I do not know how Isler could not be voted on as player of the year. When CCH needed a win or played a ranked opponent it was typically Isler who was on the mound. If you take him away from this team, they lose ALOT. Although CCH has some good pitchers, none of them are the dominate type that will shut down a good team. Also, don't forget Isler hasn't been too shabby with the bat himself.