Would be just like tires on your car- best would be for each player to decide- big heavy lineman and scat back would not have same requirement-old turf/new turf- wet turf/dry turf- grass all would be different.
It would be stupid to have these two kids play freshman football again (and the HHS coaching staff is not stupid). It will be a great opportunity for them to get an extra year at JV football and more time to develop into varsity players.
There are a lot of kids on this list. Just curious why you would leave off Nick True, 6'5" 220 starting center for the NKY Tarheels who finished 8th in the nation at the D1 AAU national tournament?