May 30, 200917 yr I would have all of those in front of him too. That's the elite level to me. I'd have him on the next tier of really, really good players. Duncan and O'neal were elite (at their pos.- like Howard now) an elite, just getting old now. 1. Lebron (I got James first and I'm a Lakers fan) 2. Kobe 3. Wade 4. Howard 5. CP3 6. Duncan 7. KG 8. Dirk 9. Melo 10. Nash/ D Williams/ Amare, Roy, Bosh, O'neal (legend)- and a host of others. Duncan may not even be Top 10 let alone the 6th best player in the NBA...You're Top 5 looks spot on though IMO.
May 30, 200917 yr Duncan may not even be Top 10 let alone the 6th best player in the NBA...You're Top 5 looks spot on though IMO. I got to have one old timer in my top ten, but I agree. This year he wasn't a top ten player. However, I'd still have him as a top ten player in the league. This is probably the last year. Even though he was still second All NBA. Not many power forward you'd take over him still today.
May 31, 200917 yr Author LeBron James Kobe Bryant Dwyane Wade Carmelo Anthony Chris Paul Dwight Howard Kevin Durant Brandon Roy Tim Duncan Deron Williams/Manu Ginobli/Tony Parker What has Melo done to be rated ahead of Paul or Howard?
May 31, 200917 yr What has Melo done to be rated ahead of Paul or Howard? Nothing. Howard is proving his worth tonight, he is beasting on the Cavs.:taz:
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.