I would go with Cassel. Sure, he hasn't established himself yet, but he's still throwing the ball to Randy Moss and Wes Welker, the guy is going to get you some points.

^

 

I was thinking the same thing.

Garrard

Cassel...I'd try him out. Campbell is struggling in the new offense. The Jags o-line has been hit hard with injuries...

 

Cassel is an unknown, but he's surrounded by the most offensive talent and he's been in their system for several years. I think I'd take a shot on him this week.

 

If not him, then definitely Garrard, IMO. He played well last year and the Jags faced one of the best defenses in the league last week. He should bounce back at some point. I like Garrard, but their offensive line situation worries me because they thrive on running the ball. If they can't run the ball effectively because of poor line play, I'm not as confident in Garrard carrying the load with no help.

Cassell, he still has all the weapons at his disposal.

Garrard. He had a terrible week 1. The man rarely throws INT's, he will make the passes to get you some fantasy points, and he runs too. I think he is a better pick than those other two.

Garrard. He had a terrible week 1. The man rarely throws INT's, he will make the passes to get you some fantasy points, and he runs too. I think he is a better pick than those other two.

:thumb::thumb:

 

If Cassell has a decent week this week, I would cut Campbell, there is no reason to have three QB's.

One thing to consider with Garrard is that if the Jags o-line plays poorly, it may very well mean that he'll be running more, which could give his value a big boost.

 

I agree with FKW, if Cassel looks good, I'd get rid of Campbell. This week, Campbell isn't even in the discussion. It's between Garrard and Cassel, and I think I'd roll the dice and take a shot on Cassel.

After reading what all you guys have said, I think I'm gonna go with Cassel.

A guy that last started in high school or aguy who finished in the top 12 of QB's in most leagues last year is a no brainer. Garrard will fininsh in the top 12 again this year.