I think fans too often want to see local players play D1, but I don't always see this as the best thing for the athlete. If they are the RARE breed who can be successful and play significant roles on D1 schools, then by all means, go there. However, just being a great high school football player does not correlate to playing time at the D1 level (just see David Jones at UK. GREAT high school running back, and he's found a role at UK, but NEVER is in the mix for one of their running back spots; yes, I know he is playing some defense, but you see my point).

 

The way I see it, if you are one of these types of players, which 99% of ALL great high school players are, then why go D1 as a walk-on and be a scout team player? I would go to a smaller school with them paying, ala Georgetown or Centre, and be able to start, contribute, and play the great game on the next level. It's not a knock, except to a few fan's egos who truly have good intentions, but want to be able to say, "Player X, from our school, is playing D1".

 

 

Another point that seems to be lost in the great D1 debate is value. Financially speaking the "financial packages" offered by either NAIA or DII schools are worth more than a "full ride" at an in state D1.

Also congrats to Mr. May and all of the guys going on to play on Saturdays.

I agree with you 100% Grover, I would rather be a bigger fish in a small pond than vice versa.

 

 

Your point may be lost on David Jones, though. He was not recruited as an offensive player, he was recruited to play DB.

 

I understand that, but that is the point also. Yes, he was recruited to play defense, but he was an OUTSTANDING running back. If he was good enough to overtake Little, Locke, etc..., he would be in the backfield. Anyway, I'm not disagreeing with you.

I understand that, but that is the point also. Yes, he was recruited to play defense, but he was an OUTSTANDING running back. If he was good enough to overtake Little, Locke, etc..., he would be in the backfield. Anyway, I'm not disagreeing with you.

 

I understand what you're saying now and it is a good point. :thumb:

Congrats Dustin! Very sound decision in picking Georgetown. Great program and an even better school.