I would be tempted to consider a handful of outfielders - Ichiro, Edmunds, A. Jones, Paul Blair, Evans all come to mind.

You seem to be enamoured by Mays. Tell us about all your first hand observations of his play.

 

You were going by your observations of Jones on TBS and ESPN. That's all well and good but if you read the observations of former playera (many of which are coaches/managers now) and sportswriters that have covered both the same player wins--Mays. Besides if you want to base that on diving catches Jim Edmonds would be the greatest center fielder--he made 2-3 a week. Andruw Jones has had one of the worst zone ratings in the majors the last couple of years and is rated as a below average center fielder by pro scouts--and he's only what 32 or so. Sorry, he just didn't do it long enough.