Trade Advice

[SnottieDrippen]

I don't think so. I'd be giving up a guy that never leaves my bench.

 

He's playing your Pats fandom against you. Tell him to kick rocks.

[MJAlltheWay24]

My RBs currently suck, but you're correct, I don't need the trade. But Ryan being the #1 ranked QB does me no good because he's not leaving my bench.

 

We aren't even factoring in that Dion Lewis might be back in a few weeks. James White could just be a rental for a few weeks. You need more than that for Ryan. Plus you'll still use Ryan during Brady's bye week.

 

But I know what ya mean, pointless to keep him and want to turn him into something.

[plantmanky]

He's playing your Pats fandom against you. Tell him to kick rocks.

 

Turn it against him, tell him you want Gronk to get Brady.

[UKMustangFan]

We aren't even factoring in that Dion Lewis might be back in a few weeks. James White could just be a rental for a few weeks. You need more than that for Ryan. Plus you'll still use Ryan during Brady's bye week.

 

But I know what ya mean, pointless to keep him and want to turn him into something.

 

I have a suspicion Lewis isn't going to see the field until the latest possible return date (Week 14).

[SnottieDrippen]

Turn it against him, tell him you want Gronk to get Brady.

 

I like the thinking here, but has Gronk met his games missed quota for the season?

[HammerTime]

So the overall opinion on the deal is no. Fair enough.

 

Does anyone's opinion change if I'm able to talk him into Stewart for Ryan?

 

It makes him a lot better. It barely moves the needle for you IMO.

[plantmanky]

I like the thinking here, but has Gronk met his games missed quota for the season?

 

Fair point, thats why I have never drafted him.

[plantmanky]

UKMF I will summarize my thoughts on the trade proposal like this.

 

You would be better off trading for Votto.

[UKMustangFan]

So different team just sent me this offer....

 

Dez Bryant & Kniles Davis for Matt Ryan.

 

 

His team:

Kirk Cousins

Kniles Davis

Mike Gillasee

Ryan Mathews

Lesean McCoy

CJ Anderson

Dez

Mike Evans

Marvin Jones Jr

Cameron Meredith

Kelvin Benjamin

Cameron Brate

@HammerTime @Bench @MJAlltheWay24 @plantmanky @SnottieDrippen

[UKMustangFan]

FWIW, Dak is on the waiver wire for me to pick up as my backup to Brady...

[plantmanky]

Is Bryant back healthy?

[HammerTime]

I hate that you can't see Dez healthy one time before you pulled the trigger. If I knew he was coming back 100% I'd do it. Kniles Davis does nothing for me in that trade.

[UKMustangFan]

Is Bryant back healthy?

 

He's practicing and all indications are that he will be after the bye this week.

 

 

Should I maybe try to get him to change Davis to Ryan Mathews or a different back?

[MJAlltheWay24]

I have a suspicion Lewis isn't going to see the field until the latest possible return date (Week 14).

 

Don't do that to me UKMF. I was hoping week 10, after the bye.

[MJAlltheWay24]

He's practicing and all indications are that he will be after the bye this week.

 

 

Should I maybe try to get him to change Davis to Ryan Mathews or a different back?

 

Yes. Kniles Davis doesn't do anything for me either. Try for CJ Anderson, be nice to squeeze a WR too.