Let me explain....Singers have (had) American Idol, X Factor, The Voice, etc. The other acts have AGT. So yes, they're absolutely allowed to be there, but I hate when they go far.

 

I've watched the show for quite a few seasons, and the same rhetoric is always used by the judges when judging non-musical acts..."I feel like it's the same thing every time just with different props". Umm, sorry but singers are doing the exact same thing every single time they take the stage. They simply change the song they're doing.

 

I see what you're saying. But, they ARE allowed on there. Should they not have a fair shot just because there are other shows catering only to singers?

I see what you're saying. But, they ARE allowed on there. Should they not have a fair shot just because there are other shows catering only to singers?

 

Of course they deserve a fair shot. Doesn't mean I have to want any of them to do well though. :lol2:

Of course they deserve a fair shot. Doesn't mean I have to want any of them to do well though. :lol2:

 

:lol: :lol:

 

Haterade!

^The Clairvoyants and the magician were easily the two best acts on the show IMO.

 

I can't stand when singing acts go far. They have plenty of shows that are solely for singers, this is for everyone and anyone.

 

I with you. I really liked Linkin Bridge and wanted them to win, but the Clairvoyants and Eagles player were by far the best two. I was a big fan of Victor the Juggler too.

No one is going to Vegas to see the young girl sing.

No one is going to Vegas to see the young girl sing.

 

So she shouldn't have won because of that?

 

Would anyone honestly take a trip to Vegas to see any of them?

 

Also, thought I read that they have the option of the Vegas show, so they don't necessarily have to do it. She'll get the $1M and sign a nice record deal and be on her way.

No one is going to Vegas to see the young girl sing.

 

I wouldn't go to the park down the street from where I live and watch her sing for free.

I wouldn't go to the park down the street from where I live and watch her sing for free.

 

:lol2:

 

I like her sound. My wife wanted to fast-forward thru her performances. She's definitely not for everyone.

So she shouldn't have won because of that?

 

Would anyone honestly take a trip to Vegas to see any of them?

 

Also, thought I read that they have the option of the Vegas show, so they don't necessarily have to do it. She'll get the $1M and sign a nice record deal and be on her way.

 

My comment was not intending to say anything other than what it said. She is not going to attract a crowd in Vegas.

 

I do think a few of the other finalists (non-singers) are, indeed, the kind of acts one would go see in Vegas.

:lol2:

 

I like her sound. My wife wanted to fast-forward thru her performances. She's definitely not for everyone.

 

I'm not saying she's not talented. She does have a different/unique sound as you say. She is talented. She can write her own songs.

 

However, how much are you willing to pay and how long are you willing to listen to her perform?

My comment was not intending to say anything other than what it said. She is not going to attract a crowd in Vegas.

 

I do think a few of the other finalists (non-singers) are, indeed, the kind of acts one would go see in Vegas.

 

I'm in Vegas to drink, gamble, eat, and be awesome. None of those would include going to a show.

I'm not saying she's not talented. She does have a different/unique sound as you say. She is talented. She can write her own songs.

 

However, how much are you willing to pay and how long are you willing to listen to her perform?

 

I'd buy her album for sure.

See Brooks, Garth. Chesney, Kenny. Truckers, Drive-By.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

:lol2:

 

You were doing pretty good until you got to the third one. Their lyrics are too smart to fit in with those other cornballs.

I tend to agree with most here, the two magic acts were the best. I was pulling for the Eagles player.

 

Again Linkin Bridge just wasn't that special to me. A group of guys singing accapella has been done 2 million times. I also didn't think their last performance was that good.

 

Of the signing acts I like Brian Justin a run the best. However his act got tired as well. He basically did the same thing everytime just with a different song. Didn't really care for final either.

Again Linkin Bridge just wasn't that special to me. A group of guys singing accapella has been done 2 million times. I also didn't think their last performance was that good.

 

It wasn't their best. I thought their best was Free Bird & 7 Years.