I can agree with Walls, Parrish, Adams and maybe Spears last year. He did not have the Offensive year in 05 that he had in 2004. Parrish and Walls had great years offensively and defensively. Both were phenominal this year.
I agree with Firebird if I were starting a team of All Stars in the 15th, Josh would be my 1st player chosen. This again isnt taking anything away from anyone else, just my opinion.