October 12, 201114 yr I'd rather have Williams. Both are #1's, so the difference to me is their teams. Williams has a much better QB at this point with Thomas working with the rookie Gabbert. Also, Williams is a better red zone target at 6'1, 221 pounds. He's off to a slow start, but he did catch 11 TD's last year and he is still the most targeted guy on Tampa's team. Thomas is only 5'8, so it doesn't seem likely that he'll have double digit TD upside. Bottom line: I think Williams worst-case will give you similar production to what you'll get from Thomas. His upside is much bigger.
October 12, 201114 yr Yeah, that's who I went with... Also, do you think it's wise for me to attempt to turn Stafford (I have Kolb & A. Smith on my bench), into McFadden or McCoy if possible?
October 12, 201114 yr Author Yeah, that's who I went with... Also, do you think it's wise for me to attempt to turn Stafford (I have Kolb & A. Smith on my bench), into McFadden or McCoy if possible? I think yes.
October 12, 201114 yr I think yes. Just got offered some sort of combination of CJ2K or Best & either DJax or White for Stafford. Should I pull the trigger on it or turn it down and go after Run DMC?
October 12, 201114 yr Just got offered some sort of combination of CJ2K or Best & either DJax or White for Stafford. Should I pull the trigger on it or turn it down and go after Run DMC? He's giving you a upper level RB and WR for Stafford? I'd jump on that. Even if you can get McFadden, I doubt you'll get a top notch WR to boot. I'd prefer CJ2K. I think he'll get going at some point. I'd also probably prefer White, since he gets targeted more consistently. I could see either guy really.
October 12, 201114 yr Author Brandon Marshall @ NYJ or Marques Colston @ TB I think Colston...who knows what Marshall will do with a new QB.
October 12, 201114 yr Author He's giving you a upper level RB and WR for Stafford? I'd jump on that. Even if you can get McFadden, I doubt you'll get a top notch WR to boot. I'd prefer CJ2K. I think he'll get going at some point. I'd also probably prefer White, since he gets targeted more consistently. I could see either guy really. I like where 5wide is at on this as well UKMF. Big trade offer.
October 12, 201114 yr He's giving you a upper level RB and WR for Stafford? I'd jump on that. Even if you can get McFadden, I doubt you'll get a top notch WR to boot. I'd prefer CJ2K. I think he'll get going at some point. I'd also probably prefer White, since he gets targeted more consistently. I could see either guy really. I'm really lucking out with this one I think. White and CJ2K are top 3-4 at their positions, but are having down years so far. Bringing in Stafford will essentially give him more production on a weekly basis than he's been getting from those two, and it will give me the semblance of a really solid starting unit. I'd have QB: Smith/Kolb (depending on matchups) WR: White WR: Holmes RB: CJ2K RB: Gore TE: Finley FLEX:Blount/Sproles I like where 5wide is at on this as well UKMF. Big trade offer.
October 12, 201114 yr How do you all see Eric Decker's value with Tebow at the helm? I have Decker and I'm not optimistic that he'll do much of anything with Tebow. Of course, you never know. I'm just going to wait and see. He may be a guy who can get free and make plays on Tebow's scrambles.
October 12, 201114 yr Author I'm really lucking out with this one I think. White and CJ2K are top 3-4 at their positions, but are having down years so far. Bringing in Stafford will essentially give him more production on a weekly basis than he's been getting from those two, and it will give me the semblance of a really solid starting unit. I'd have QB: Smith/Kolb (depending on matchups) WR: White WR: Holmes RB: CJ2K RB: Gore TE: Finley FLEX:Blount/Sproles I certainly like it more than where you were before all these trades.
October 14, 201114 yr Author One of my usual starters is on a bye (CJ2K) so I will probably have to start a WR. I'm definitely starting Dez Bryant, so please...pick 2 of the following. Brandon Marshall @ Jets - Last time he was on Revis Island he didn't fair to well at all. Anquan Boldin vs. Houston Michael Crabtree @ Detroit David Nelson @ Giants
October 14, 201114 yr What does everyone think about this trade ? I give up Bradshaw and Jacobs I receive Mendenhaul and Felix Jones .
October 14, 201114 yr Author I would think that you easily do that trade Wildcat Dad and don't look back.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.