Fantasy Team Evaluation/Trade Question

[Cdirty107]

Don't ask me why I thought this may be a keeper league, but I did. Guess it's because I'm drafting one right now and that's how my thought process works. I'd actually stick with McCallister if you're in a redraft league, he'll probably out perform Lynch this year.

[formerkywrestler]

Your team isn't bad at all. Though I don't see why you need 3 Qb's and 2 TE's.

 

And I'd personally rather have Edge then Deuce, so I'd say no to the trade.

[sports fan]

I think Edge will have a big year, and Duece will see fewer and fewer touches as Bush continues to improve. I think Leinart (and Losman for that matter) will be servicable QBs, so I would not make the trade. However, if you are set on Kitna, and are still weighing the Duece vs. Lynch thing, I think Duece may score more than Lynch in the first half of the season, but the tables will turn drastically in the second half of the season.

[Lucky Charms]

Your team isn't bad at all. Though I don't see why you need 3 Qb's and 2 TE's.

 

And I'd personally rather have Edge then Deuce, so I'd say no to the trade.

:thumb:

Just see what J.P. Losman does first. Could be a sleeper this year.

 

I'd keep Edge over Duece too.

[OldRaider22]

Definite YES on the trade. The sheer number of opportunities for Deuce to score will translate into him having a better season than Edge. Not only that, but your upgrading at QB to Kitna, who I also really like this year. And you get Morency to go with Jackson, essentially giving you the starter in GB(and a 3rd RB) no matter how that race shakes out. The only thing I might suggest is to remove the peripheral players such as the TE's and kickers, unless those are somehow "deal breakers". I see this all the time, someone throws in this TE and this kicker and somehow the deal is supposed to be sweeter??:lol:

[DragonFire]

Your team isn't bad at all. Though I don't see why you need 3 Qb's and 2 TE's.

 

And I'd personally rather have Edge then Deuce, so I'd say no to the trade.

 

I have three QBs because I'm taking a QBBC approach more or less. I think Leinart will be my starter most weeks with playing Losman on matchup possibilities. Green was more or less a flier that I took just in case he takes off this year. I'd say if he sits on my roster 4-5 weeks doing nothing that I'll drop him. The two TEs are due to roster requirements. We have 18 players maximimum, with minimums of 2 QBs, 4 RBs, 4 WRs, 2 TEs, 2 PKs, 2 DEF. Two extra roster spots can be used any way you please.

[DragonFire]

I appreciate the advice guys, though I ultimately went against the trade. The reason why was ultimately I feel deep down that Edge is better, at least potentially, than either of the two RBs he was offering me. Also, I think the improvement to his team was significant since he would have LT, Edge, and then Lynch as a backup, and this would come about by giving up a 6th round pick in Kitna that ultimately was just his backup QB. So that played into it somewhat. I may explore the idea of doing this trade further down the road since I think he'll still be open to dropping a backup QB at that point if it means an improvement.