Fantasy Trade Advice

[MJAlltheWay24]

Would you trade Todd Gurley for Carlos Hyde straight up? It's a keeper league and no limit on how long you can keep a player. No PPR.

Edited September 18, 2015 by MJAlltheWay24

[Jumper_Dad]

Wow after one week of Hyde as a starter you'd have to consider it. Some are saying Gurley is the next RB Superstar...tough choice. If you think Gurley is the next AP then you keep him.

 

I have Hyde in one league and Gurley in another one...get back to me at the end of the year...:lol2:

[NamecipS]

Lot's of If/Then's around this one.

 

I'd probably keep Gurley. He's going to be very good. The Rams D is going to keep them in games allowing the offense to grind it out and eat up clock. Fischer's a good coach and is slowing turning them in to a really good team.

 

I'm not big on Hyde.

[MJAlltheWay24]

Yeah there are definitely a ton of ifs in this one, which makes it fun. It's not officially on the table but the guy is very interested in Gurley and he has Hyde.

 

Long term, I'd kick the heck out of myself if Gurley turns out to be as good as actually advertised.

 

Mainly wanted to post to get some fantasy conversation going. Boring day.

[NEERFAN]

I'd keep Gurley. I passed on AP his rookie year in a keeper and I still regret it.