You are right Hatz. After further review, Boyle holds a 5-3 advantage. With the exception of last year, these games have all been blowouts. Average margin of victory for the winner is 29.5 points (Boyle's 5 wins m.o.v. is 30.8 pts., HC's 3 wins m.o.v. is 27.3 pts)
2001 Boyle 32-0 @ Boyle
2002 Boyle 35-0 @ HC
2003 Boyle 46-7 @ Boyle
2004 Boyle 45-21 @ Commonwealth
2005 HC 48-13 @ Boyle
2006 HC 53-10 @ HC
2007 HC 47-43 @ Boyle
2008 Boyle 31-7 @ HC