I dont know that the above picture really tells whether he was safe or not. If you look at the series of pictures Snyder catches the ball on the first base side and swipes it down. So the picture really doesnt say much he could have already tagged him by that point.
Completly agree with you. Even though it was a bad throw the first basemen needs to block that ball and keep the runners at third and first. Instead it gave NCC a run and a runner in scoring position.
Hmm maybe this will help everybody narrow it down:
Division 1 POY- Darner, Maile
Division 2 POY- Hunter Jones
If i do remember correctly they give a POY award away to two separate divisions so there should not even be a debate involving Hunter and the CCH boys