October 11, 201114 yr Why did the trade get processed without your approval?This is what I want to know. If the two guys somehow conspired to get the trade through without your approval then I would without a doubt reverse it. If Yahoo passed the trade because you as commisioner let the time lapse then this rests clearly on your shoulders. My argument would be by not making an action within the time parameters you have implicitly allowed the trade. If this is the case the trade should stand. It's not the guys making the trade at fault here but the commish.
October 11, 201114 yr This is what I want to know. If the two guys somehow conspired to get the trade through without your approval then I would without a doubt reverse it. If Yahoo passed the trade because you as commisioner let the time lapse then this rests clearly on your shoulders. My argument would be by not making an action within the time parameters you have implicitly allowed the trade. If this is the case the trade should stand. It's not the guys making the trade at fault here but the commish. That's what I was thinking. If the league is set to require approval from the commish, it wouldn't have gone through without it. If there's a time period for approval that elapsed, then that is the same as approval. It is hard for me to see any justification for reversing the trade.
October 11, 201114 yr Author This is what I want to know. If the two guys somehow conspired to get the trade through without your approval then I would without a doubt reverse it. If Yahoo passed the trade because you as commisioner let the time lapse then this rests clearly on your shoulders. My argument would be by not making an action within the time parameters you have implicitly allowed the trade. If this is the case the trade should stand. It's not the guys making the trade at fault here but the commish. I'm allowing it to stand. I can't penalize them for a system glitch/error. The trade was offered at 10:30 AM Sunday, and accepted at 11:00 AM. I have it set up where I have sole reviewership of trades, and a time period of one day to review all trades. I never received an email regarding the proposed trade. No idea how it went through, but I've decided that the fairest course of action is to allow it to stand.
October 11, 201114 yr ^ I would be red hot mad if I lost because of that system error. :lol: How did anyone know you didn't approve it? Wouldn't they just assume once it was processed you approved the trade?
October 11, 201114 yr Author ^ I would be red hot mad if I lost because of that system error. :lol: How did anyone know you didn't approve it? Wouldn't they just assume once it was processed you approved the trade? They didn't know I didn't. They were asking when they made the trade because one minute Fitz was starting against them, then after the games started he was nowhere to be found, and Turner was in his place. They asked when it went through, and when I answered "what trade?" that got them going. :lol:
October 11, 201114 yr I'm allowing it to stand. I can't penalize them for a system glitch/error. The trade was offered at 10:30 AM Sunday, and accepted at 11:00 AM. I have it set up where I have sole reviewership of trades, and a time period of one day to review all trades. I never received an email regarding the proposed trade. No idea how it went through, but I've decided that the fairest course of action is to allow it to stand. :thumb: :thumb: You made the right move. I've been a commish for 10+ years in various leagues and it sucks. If I didn't start this Bad QB league I'd be free from it.
October 12, 201114 yr You made the correct decision. I haven't had a serious issue arrive yet but it's bound to happen at least once per year.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.