March 23, 201511 yr Author I have no idea who the other Red would be.. And he is higher than Reynolds, Stubbs, Dunn.. I'll throw in these names: Pedro Alvarez Carlos Pena Chris Davis Uggla not being on there threw me off. Chris Davis is #4 at 31%. Carlos Pena is #11 .
March 23, 201511 yr Author So were 3 or 4 of the top 10 Reds? 4. #1 (still not listed) was a Red. 3 years with Reds. Probably most associated with Cleveland.
March 23, 201511 yr Author Mike Cameron is probably #1 if it's a former Red. He K'd A LOT. Cameron was #19 .
March 23, 201511 yr Author #3 moved around but mainly with Oakland. I would NEVER have even thought of this cat. #5 is a current MLB catcher.
March 24, 201511 yr #3 moved around but mainly with Oakland. I would NEVER have even thought of this cat. #5 is a current MLB catcher. Jack Cust? I just got to the thread and he's one of the first guys that I thought about but I don't know if he had enough plate appearances. He was the poster child for the 3 true outcome guys. For catcher is it Saltalmacchia? He regularly broke 120 K's with Boston in about 120 games each year.
March 24, 201511 yr Author Jack Cust? I just got to the thread and he's one of the first guys that I thought about but I don't know if he had enough plate appearances. He was the poster child for the 3 true outcome guys. For catcher is it Saltalmacchia? He regularly broke 120 K's with Boston in about 120 games each year. Correct on both.
March 24, 201511 yr Correct on both. If Cust had the plate appearances I was pretty sure on him--especially when you gave the A's clue. I'd have never gotten Salty without the hint that it was an active catcher.
March 24, 201511 yr 4. #1 (still not listed) was a Red. 3 years with Reds. Probably most associated with Cleveland. Is it Russ Branyan?
March 24, 201511 yr Stubbs is 6th. 29.7% The biggest waste of talent on this list. At least most of the others are boppers, likely to get thrown out on routine ground balls and very unlikely to steal a base if they get there. Every Stubbs K is a lost potential double on a simple ground ball. Bunt attempts alone should have kept him off this list.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.