Who would win?

I think the 1990's team would win easily. With all due respect, it may be that the early 90's Fairdale team by itself could beat the 2000's all-star team. The same may be true if you added Greg Buckner to the mid-90's University Heights team (Greg Buckner graduated from UHA a few years prior to the UHA teams with his brother Andre (Duke), Lamont Barnes (Temple), Isiah Victor (Tennessee) and Harold Swanagan (Notre Dame)).

1990. No question. You could take a half-decade team from either and just use the loaded front half or back half to be able to beat the 2010's IMO.

Do the players here actually have to have made the State All-Tournament team? Under the 2000's rules, there'd be some good players left off just based on how the awards were set up.