Jump to content

ed2

Suspended
  • Posts

    112
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by ed2

  1. For those of you that think this isn't a rivalry between these two schools, you are fooling yourselves. Largest home crowd of the season for Highlands. I would argue probably largest crowd for CCH vs a NKY opponent. Why would all those people continue to come? I know why, because it's HHS/CCH! And listening to comments on the field and heading to the cars, post-game, nothing really out of character, "Go Pulaski" by one passerby, and 100% true comment by another in "can't believe they ran the score up", I can gaureentee its still a rivalry. And oh yeah, the basketball season just got a bit interesting too! That will be fun. That rivalry by some just jumped 1000% if that's possible.

     

    Folks, it's still a rivalry!

     

    Ran up the score?

  2. I forsee lots of home schooled basketball players in Jefferson County.

    [/b]

    Why would you think home schooled kids can't get into college?

    We've all seen an athlete or two (or twenty) over the years that has struggled to make the grades they needed to in order to stay eligible. Home schooling CAN be a great thing for some kids, but it has no requirements for testing - standardized or otherwise. What is to stop the parent of an athletically gifted and academically impaired student from pulling them out of the school system and "home schooling" them in order to let them play sports for the local school of jurisdiction without having to keep their grades up any longer?

     

    That's what I was thinking by the original statement about more home schooled kids in Jefferson county. I was questioning whether that is because a kid can't keep grades at the high school, but mom/dad can home school and suddenly they have the grades. (academic fraud the right term?)

     

    So if I had to home school my son to keep him eligible to play basketball, what would be the point? Meaning if I'm fudging the home grades, he isn't getting into college.

     

    Is Jefferson county an open district?

  3. SECTION 1. A NEW SECTION OF KRS CHAPTER 158 IS CREATED TO READ AS FOLLOWS:

    (1) A student enrolled in a nonpublic school, including a home school, is eligible to participate in an interscholastic extracurricular activity sponsored by or engaged in by the public school to which the student would be assigned according to district school board attendance policies or which the student could choose to attend pursuant to district open enrollment provisions, only if the nonpublic school does not offer the interscholastic extracurricular activity. A student eligible under this section who is selected to participate in an interscholastic extracurricular activity shall:

     

    (e) Comply with the same physical examination, immunization, insurance, age, and semester eligibility requirements as other students participating in the activity.

    -Negates the anti-immunization reason for home schooling

  4. I'm not for the bill, but as I've read it several times, it doesn't seem to be most of the end of the world scenarios that have been brought up in the thread.

    If anything I'd think there would be smaller private schools that would like it.

     

    It is pretty limited.

    The student must be in non-public school or home schooled.

    The private school can't have the extracurricular activity.

    IF the school district that they actually live in has it, they can participate at that public school.

     

    Can't see where it would impact a school like CovCath - where a non-CovCath student wanted to play there.

    i.e. a home schooled kid couldn't tryout for their basketball team.

    It COULD benefit a CovCath student wanted to join an archery team, that doesn't exist at CovCath. AND they live in Ft Mitchell, AND Beechwood has an archery team.

     

    I'm thinking a school like Calvary Christian.

    No Football. No Swimming.

     

    If a kid there wanted to play football they could play at the public school in their district. Assume they live in Taylor Mill.

    This student could play for Scott, or any of the Kenton Co schools in the open enrollment.

    But that student couldn't say I want to play at CovCath or Highlands.

     

    I still don't like it - except for cases like the wheelchair bound archery enthusiast example mentioned above somewhere.

     

    Home schooling or attending a particular private school is a choice. Factor in everything in the choice and live with it. Life isn't always a buffet where you can pick only the things you like. Sometimes the menu says "no substitutions". That's just the way it is.

  5. Perhaps they should have spent less time whooping it up at lineman challenges and spent the time in a more productive manner like improving footwork and quickness of the ball. The three lineman are/were recruited because they have the one thing that you cannot teach, size. All three have a long way to go if they ever want to see the football field at the collegiate level.

     

    They are some big ole boys, but that didn't translate into much.

    Defenses seemed to get around them fairly easily.

  6. Private school parents pay taxes to the district. Should they also get the tax break? And I'll go back to the scenario I posited earlier. Using the same logic should a kid going to a private school be allowed to play for the public school in their district if their school doesn't field a team in their sport of choice?

     

    That seems to be the scenario that the bill addresses specifically.

    If CovCath doesn't have an archery team, and Dixie (where my kid lives) does, they could join that team...

     

    The way it is written...

     

    It doesn't say anything about what if your district doesn't have it, regardless of private or home schooled.

  7. We don't often disagree, but here we do. They pay taxes in that district, they should be allowed to play in that district. Otherwise, maybe they should propose a bill to get a tax break on the amount of school taxes they pay. Just spitballing.

     

    Paying taxes in a district gives you the right to go to the school.

    Going to the school gives you the opportunity to play sports there.

     

    So would every parent sending their kids to private school also get the tax break since they don't send their kid to school in the district?

    Or the senior citizens next door that don't even have grandkids in the district, shouldn't they get a tax break too?

  8. I just read the bill and it doesn't sound like the CovCath scenario applies.

    It says they can play for the public school for the district in which they reside.

     

    So a kid that goes to CovCath or is home schooled, and doesn't have a blah blah team could play blah blah for Dixie since that's where they leave. But nothing that I read in the bill gives them any rights to doing anything at CovCath if they are home schooled.

  9. Seems like a pretty STUPID idea to me.

    The teams are SCHOOL TEAMS, comprised of students OF THE SCHOOL.

    A home schooled kid is not part of that school community, family, student body, or whatever you want to call it.

    If your kids want's to play a sport, there are rec leagues, select, aau or whatever.

    If that is not good enough, then you have a decision to make. Send your kid to school and play sports, or don't. Seems pretty simple.

     

    Now, there can be some sort of exception or special circumstances. I'm not sure if an action out of Frankfort is needed (because those always turn out well) or required. I would have thought that it could be something KHSAA could handle as a matter of eligibility.

    i.e. the above referenced wheelchair bound student.

    The comment states that they are receiving assistance from the school. So in this case, it would appear that home schooling was not necessarily a personal choice, but one dictated wholly or substantially based on the physical ability/inability to attend class on campus. Depending on the "assistance" being provided by the school, one could argue that the individual is a student of the school and eligible for the archery team.

     

    I don't understand the private school arguments on here though. Did I miss something in here somewhere that said a home schooled kid could pick which school, to include a private school like CovCath? Or was that commentary because the bill was written so poorly that a loop hole exists that could be exploited in some way? I mean there is no explicit or implied right of anyone to attend our school, let alone play a sport for it. Public schools don't have that same argument.

  10. I've often said that I fully respect the talent and the hard work required for cheerleading but I simply cannot stand a lot that goes with it. Don't even get me started on the sexualization you now see of girls as young as 6 years old. Cheer moms CAN be the worst.

     

    NO DOUBT!

    My girls started doing it at 5 & 6 yrs old back in the early 2000's.

    Competitions were like auditions to get into a grades 1-12 stripper academy.

     

    Some of these competition squads are phenomenal. More athletic than some other sports teams - boys and girls.

    They also have their own brand of extreme crazy!

     

    Isn't Texas where there is something happen every year around this stuff? A mom paying someone to "hurt" another girl on the squad to get a spot for her daughter type of thing?

  11. Was thinking exactly the same thing earlier.

    The actions of the professors - (who should be fired and investigated by the police if the student was touched) - their actions invalidate the protest. Regardless of what the protest was about.

    It's the basic pattern of protesters, particularly on the left.

    "We can do or say whatever we want. The rules don't apply to us. Agree with us or you are wrong".

     

    The next story will be about the protesters demanding that they get A's for all the assignments that they missed because they skipped class.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using the site you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use Policies.