Updated Maher Rankings 9/10

[SoccerMath]

The boys rankings have been updated. Let us know what you think, and please report score errors.

 

Full rankings:

Maher Rankings | Kentucky High School Soccer Rankings

 

top 20

KY-1 St. Xavier

KY-2 Daviess County

KY-3 Oldham County

KY-4 Trinity (Louisville)

KY-5 Louisville Collegiate

KY-6 Covington Catholic

KY-7 Woodford County

KY-8 Mercer County

KY-9 DuPont Manual

KY-10 Paul Laurence Dunbar

KY-11 South Warren

KY-12 Highlands

KY-13 Madison Central

KY-14 Lafayette

KY-15 Ballard

KY-16 Hopkinsville

KY-17 Ryle

KY-18 Henry Clay

KY-19 Christian Academy-Louisville

KY-20 Bowling Green

[drew4489]

ballard beats number 6 cov cath. cov cath stays in the same spot. ballard loses to number 1 st x. and drops one spot. very confused. also, are maxpreps rankings any better or worse then maher?

Edited September 12, 2016 by drew4489

[groinpull]

ballard beats number 6 cov cath. cov cath stays in the same spot. ballard loses to number 1 st x. and drops one spot. very confused. also, are maxpreps rankings any better or worse then maher?

 

I can't say I disagree with your statement. Hard to figure this out.

[Goal15]

I haven't gone through this with a fine tooth comb, but movement in rankings aren't based on just what one team has done. It is also based on what other teams do. So maybe other teams moving up or down affected Ballard.

[drew4489]

the only part about the updated rankings that makes since is st x moving to number one. how does cov cath stay where they were if they lost to team way further down then them?

Edited September 12, 2016 by drew4489

[gameplayedright]

I'm not defending the Maher system and I don't know if all of Saturday 9/10 games were factored into this week's rankings. I agree with Goal15 you clearly need to take all of the week's games into the equation. As an example

CCH beat #27 McNick 5-2 (# 27 in Cincy at that time) @ McNick and tied #4 Trinity @ Trinity 1-1. Ballard lost to #3 St X (#3 at that time) 6-2 @ home. Point is you can't just factor in CCH's lost @ Ballard. Daviess CO, Oldham Co, Louisville Collegiate, and Mercer Co all went 3-0-0 last week. Woodford Co went 1-2-0. Clearly if you want to hold or move up you need to have good results Vs good teams, and you better not stub your toe at home.

[drew4489]

I completely agree with what you are saying gameplayedright and im just using the cov cath/ballard as an example. and I don't believe ballard should be above cov cath. just the fact they played each other and neither team changed positions.

[Goal15]

Probably more of a coincidence.