Page 3 of If you are like many and are bothered by the NFL's definition of a catch how would you write the rule? Advertisement 0 0 0 ... 34 comments | 1198 Views | Go to page 1 →
Dec 19, 17, 07:57 PM #31
Dec 24, 17, 01:47 PM #32
Bills player appeard to get both feet down and control of the ball....TD on the field, review No Catch! This looked more like a catch than the Steelers catch did and I thought that was a TD.
- Join Date
- Nov 06
- To one who has faith, no explanation is necessary. To one without faith, no explanation is possible
FYI Bills are playing the Pats, not that it matters I'm sure.
Dec 24, 17, 02:32 PM #33
Dec 24, 17, 02:33 PM #34
Dec 24, 17, 08:21 PM #35
- Join Date
- Nov 16
- Northern Kentucky
He never had clear control. "Control" means you have the ball in firm possession. How do people not understand what "control" means?
If that was a today when the Steelers player caught it, then is it a catch if a receiver gets his hands around it for a fraction of a second and it gets knocked out?
You need to have firm control or it leaves everything even more open to interpretation and opinions.
If he had control, then he wouldn't have fumbled it when it hit the ground.
Everyone who says "then why's it ok if a runner just gets the ball across and then fumbles it in the ai for when it hits the ground?" Because he had control of the ball while running and fully had it for a while before crossing the goal line. Case closed.
Eli Manning agrees:
Like others, as it happened Manning thought it was a clean catch. But on replay, he saw that it wasn’t.
“I was watching the game live, you see it, and it doesn’t look like an incompletion at all,’’ Manning said. “Once they slow it down and see him going to the ground and the ball hitting the ground, incompletion …
“You hate it, when you’re watching it live, you don’t even think about that not being a catch. When they run it down, hey, when you go to the ground you got to finish with the ball in your hand. When it hits the ground and there’s movement, I was like, ‘I think that’s enough evidence where they’re gonna reverse that’.”
It’s so clear to Manning, he doesn’t understand why others are confused as to what constitutes a catch in the NFL
“I think it is clear what a catch is,’’ Manning said. “Especially when you’re going to the ground, you got to control the ball the whole time. You got to have it. If the ball hits the ground, you’re going to the ground, the ball moves or hits the ground and there’s a little loss of contact through the end of the play, it’s gonna be an incompletion.’’