Page 6 of I can see why...just surprised it actually happened. Giants bench Eli Manning, Geno Smith will start on Sunday Advertisement 0 0 0 ... 84 comments | 1460 Views | Go to page 1 →
Nov 30, 17, 10:12 PM #76
Nov 30, 17, 10:16 PM #77
Nov 30, 17, 10:17 PM #78
Nov 30, 17, 10:22 PM #79
That team was dominant before the shooting.
The super bowl team in 07 was good, but very good at the right time.
The 2011 team was mostly Eli and Cruz/Nicks making up for a terrible defense. The defense got hot in the playoffs and that helped them take down Rodgers and Green Bay in Lambeau, and eventually Brady again in the super bowl. But while the defense was great in those playoffs, Eli was even better. He played his best that year imo.
Dec 1, 17, 06:45 AM #80
I listen to Dan PAtrick pretty religiously. I like the show, but I just cant wrap my head around the fact that he has referred to Eli as a future hall of famer. All they can bring up is the two superbowl championships. For me he is a good quarterback who was very fortunate in the first one. If all it takes is to have to titles to your name why isnt Jim Plunkett in? He threw far less than Eli.
- Join Date
- Jan 16
Dec 1, 17, 10:53 AM #81
He is also the best QB to ever play for a storied franchise with 4 super bowls and several NFL Championships.
Isn't the ultimate goal championships? He was fortunate in both super bowls. Almost every winner is lucky in some way. He also made several key plays that helped win both games.
Dec 1, 17, 11:55 AM #82He's number 7 all time in yards and TD's and has 2 super bowls. And it's not like he was Brad Johnson in those super bowls. Is it really a discussion whether or not he's a HOF'er?
Dec 1, 17, 12:36 PM #83
Dec 1, 17, 03:51 PM #84
Dec 6, 17, 01:19 PM #85And the interim HC has said Eli will be their starter...